War ever justified essay

The Other Civil War A sheriff in the Hudson River Valley near Albany, New York, about to go into the hills in the fall of to collect back rents from tenants on the enormous Rensselaer estate, was handed a letter: The tenants now assume the right of doing to their landlord as he has for a long time done with them, viz: You need not think this to be children's play I would not pledge for your safe return.

War ever justified essay

It does not mean to stand by the President or any other public official save exactly to the degree in which he himself stands by the country. It is patriotic to support him in so far as he efficiently serves the country. It is unpatriotic not to oppose him to the exact extent that by inefficiency or otherwise he fails in his duty to stand by the country.

In either event, it is unpatriotic not to tell the truth—whether about the President or about any one else—save in the rare cases where this would make known to the enemy information of military value which would otherwise be unknown to him.

War ever justified essay

War ever justified essay, in the legal sense, means to betray the government, to give aid and comfort to the enemy, or to counsel resistance to the laws or to measures of government having the force. There can be conduct morally as bad as legal sedition which yet may not be violation of law.

The President—any President—can by speech or action by advocating an improper peace. One form of servility consists in a slavish attitude—of the kind, incompatible with self-respecting manliness—toward any person who is powerful by reason of his office or position. A distinguished Federal judge recently wrote me as follows: Any one who did not join that chorus was liable to imprisonment for treason or sedition.

Since Marshall tried Burr for treason it has been clear that that crime cannot be committed by words, unless one acts as a spy, or gives advice to the enemy of military or naval operations. It cannot be committed by statements reflecting upon officers or measures of government.


Any one who directly advises or counsels resistance to measures of government is guilty of sedition. That is not sedition.

It is within the protection of the first amendment. The electorate cannot be qualified to perform its duty in removing incompetent officers and securing the repeal of unwise laws unless those questions may be freely discussed.

War ever justified essay

The Republic is founded upon the faith that if the American people are permitted freely to hear foolish and wise speech, a majority will choose the wise. If that faith is not justified the Republic is based on sand.

John Milton said it all in his defense of freedom of the press: Who ever knew truth to be beaten in a fair fight? The following extracts from his speeches, during war-time, about the then President ought to be illuminating to those persons who do not understand that one of the highest and most patriotic duties to be performed in his country at this time is to tell the truth whenever it becomes necessary in order to force our government to speed up the war.

It would, for example, be our highest duty to tell it if at any time we became convinced that only thereby could we shame our leaders out of hypocrisy and prevent the betrayal of human rights by peace talk of the kind which bewilders and deceives plain people.

In a speech on January 12,Lincoln justified himself for voting in favor of a resolution censuring the President for his action prior to and during the war which was still going on. Let him answer with facts and not with arguments.Is war justified for any reasons?

War Is Never Justified - ph-vs.com

59% Say Yes 41% Say No Yes ofcourse it is. There is always a reason a war is started, there are a wide variety of reasons (e.G religion, money, power, pure hatred) that can relate to each war that has erupted. Is war ever justified? Yes, yes it is. I think war can be justified.

Take for example World War 2. Dec 10,  · I believe that war can definitely be justified. History shows that peace never (or hardly ever) comes from peace. War is never a Status: Resolved. Is war ever justifiable?In the aftermath of two world wars and in the shadow of nuclear, biological, and chemical holocaust, man is living in a society where war can erupt at any time and at any place.

War is a state of intense hostility between two co /5(12). Is War Ever Justified. Can war ever be justified? War is an inevitable part of the history of humankind.


Unlike natural happenings, war is an action of people inflicted of other . Open Document. Below is an essay on "Can War Ever Be Justified" from Anti Essays, your source for research papers, essays, and term paper examples. War is not justified because of its aftermath; wars cause death, destruction, loss, strained relationships, and suffering.

One of the severe consequences of war is the loss of innocent civilians’ lives that cannot be replaced.

free essay on Can War Ever Be Justified?